Would this be discrimination?

Hi,

I was reading an article th eother day about a reporter testing a cheap supermarket suit. In the article he mentioned about entering one of the top restaurants in London, where you are required to wear a tie. If you do not have one, they will gove you one to wear.

I have my PM for Carotid sinus hypersenstivity where pressure on my neck causes confusion in my body and my heart slows or even pauses, and have been advised by the cardiologist not to wear tight collars, ties etc. as although my PM will stop me from passing out, I may still feel very unwell if my condition is triggered.

This made me think - would I be refused entry on the grounds I refuse to wear a tie for medical reasons? If so, could I claim discrimination?

Not that I am planning to visit any posh restaurantes in London - if only I could afford to - but it did make me think.

Any view?

Simon.

5 Comments

Dress Codes

by BOB 1 - 2008-09-12 05:09:59

It may be discrimination, to some degree, but if you are thinking in terms of would it break some law against discrimination, I doubt it. However the person, that cannot for medical reasons have a necktie tied around their neck, can always wear an ascot. While they may be tied they are never tied as tightly as a necktie. And then there is the clip on necktie. It doesn't even go around the neck, but clips onto the shirt collar. That shoud satisfy the stuffiest of restaurant dress codes on a tie.

Couldn't you wear it loose?

by heckboy - 2008-09-12 10:09:03

A tie weighs practically nothing and it seems to be that you could wear it so loose as to not have any pressure on your neck whatsoever. With that said, I'll bet a conversation with the manager would allow one entry.

wow...chuckling

by joy1 - 2008-09-12 10:09:08

Simon,
I think that is the oddest but most intriguing question I have read here. Giving it some thought, I would say that it could go either way. If you carry medical identification which indicates your restriction then maybe it could be discrimination...maybe. And if you want to make a fuss about it legally, then go ahead. but my recommendation would be to First speak with the restaurant Matra De and explain your problem and see if an allowance or compromise can be made.

If your not intending to go to a "tie only " restaurant, then you haven't a problem. If it's something that is a possibility of occurring, then there are ways around tight neck ware. Bow ties which are pre-tied and have adjustable straps or the clip on type.Not even the top button of your shirt need be buttoned. There are are also clip on ties and but the weight might be a factor in leaving the top button of your shirt undone or in the way it hangs if not fitted up correctly.

Talk to one of the restaurant managers or owners about possibilities or recommendations. You can always carry the bow tie in the box in your car or in a briefcase if you carry one.

Very cute. Let us know the what you find out.

joy

maybe not

by jessie - 2008-09-12 11:09:19

london is quite stuffy when it comes to dress. you might be right on. you could question it but probably get away with a small bowtie. hope this does not offend anyone. lol but brittain?????????????it does not surprize me. i was just on the cunard queen victoria where dress code was strictly adhered too. jess

Bob......

by Bionic Beat - 2008-09-13 02:09:27

You beat me to it.....lol

An ascot is the perfect solution, or a long-ish scarf tossed casually (not really) like all the rock stars wear.

I really think that if you have a word with the manager, there will be no problem and I doubt that it's discrimination.

As someone else posted, is it discrimination to NOT eat there?? lol

You can get some great meals in a local pub, no tie required and better grub! ;D


Bionic Beat

You know you're wired when...

You can take a lickin’ and keep on tickin’.

Member Quotes

Hang in there; it does get better every day!